Practice structure

Why firms keep audit and advisory apart — and how they structure for it

Last updated: 9 November 2026

Ask a CA why the firm runs two entities and the short answer is independence. A statutory auditor has to be, and be seen to be, independent of the client. The rules limit what else the same firm, and the entities around it, may do for that client.

This guide reads the structure from ICAI's own text: the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, ICAI's Code of Ethics (13th edition, Volume II, applicable from 1 April 2026), its Guidelines for Corporate Form of Practice and its LLP guidelines. It then walks through two entities billing one client. One correction up front: a separate entity does not switch the independence rules off.

The independence rule the structure is built around

ICAI's Code of Ethics names the threat that matters most here. The self-review threat is "the threat that a firm or a network firm will not appropriately evaluate the results of a previous judgment made or an activity performed by an individual within the firm or network firm as part of a non-assurance service on which the audit team will rely" (Code, Volume II, para 600.14 A1). In plain words: you cannot audit your own work.

Before taking a non-assurance service for an audit client, the firm asks two questions (para R600.15). Will the results of the service form part of, or affect, the accounting records, the internal controls or the financial statements it will give an opinion on? And will the audit team rely on judgments the firm made while doing the service? If both answers lean yes, the service is a problem.

The Companies Act, 2013 turns part of this into a hard list. Section 144, as ICAI quotes it in para 600.4 A1 of the Code, says an auditor shall provide the company only such other services as the Board or audit committee approves, and never these: accounting and book keeping services; internal audit; design and implementation of any financial information system; actuarial services; investment advisory services; investment banking services; rendering of outsourced financial services; management services; and any other kind of services as may be prescribed. Section 141(3)(i) makes a person who renders any of them to the company, its holding company or its subsidiary ineligible to be its auditor.

A separate entity does not escape it

The first thing people assume is that moving the forbidden work into a sister company solves the problem. The text says otherwise, in three places.

One: the Explanation to section 144 says "directly or indirectly" includes services rendered by a firm "through any of its partners or through its parent, subsidiary or associate entity or through any other entity, whatsoever, in which the firm or any partner of the firm has significant influence or control, or whose name or trade mark or brand is used by the firm or any of its partners".

Two: the Code says whether larger structures form a network "does not depend on whether the firms and entities are legally separate and distinct" (para 400.50 A1), and a network firm must be independent of the audit clients of the other firms in the network (para R400.51).

Three: ICAI's Guidelines for Corporate Form of Practice say that where a member's firm is statutory auditor of an entity, the management consultancy company "should not accept the internal audit or book-keeping or such other professional assignments, which are prohibited for the statutory auditor firm" (guideline 4(i)(a)).

So the separate entity is a way to organise people, records and billing. It is not a way to take a prohibited service to an audit client.

The four shapes ICAI's text allows

Which entity can hold which work depends on what ICAI and the Act permit that kind of entity to do. This is the table to check before registering anything.

What each kind of entity may carry. Sources: Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 (as amended 2022), section 25; ICAI Guidelines for Corporate Form of Practice; ICAI Council Guidelines for conversion of CA firms into LLPs (4 November 2011); ICAI Guidelines for Formation of Multi-disciplinary Partnership (from 8 July 2021). Read 9 November 2026.
EntityWhat ICAI's text saysCan it audit?
Proprietorship or partnership of CAsThe ordinary practising firm; audit, tax and other services under section 2(2) of the ActYes
LLP of CAsRegistered with ICAI under regulation 190 (Forms 117 and 18). Its objects must be the professional services allowed under section 2(2). It is subject to the same regulations as a partnership firm, and conversion "does not give any privileges, which were not earlier with the CA firms"Yes
Management consultancy companyMust have its name approved and be registered with ICAI. It may do only "Management Consultancy & Other Services", a defined list that excludes statutory audit and tax advice or representation. "No audit practice can be done in Corporate Form"No
Multi-disciplinary partnership (CAs with company secretaries, cost accountants, advocates, actuaries, architects, engineers)Approved under regulation 53B. Not eligible for Companies Act audit if non-CAs are the majority of partners, by number and by profit shareOnly with a CA majority
Any company practising as chartered accountantsSection 25: "No company, whether incorporated in India or elsewhere, shall practise as chartered accountants". An LLP that has a company as a partner counts as a company for this sectionNo

Two things in the table surprise people. A company can never be the audit entity. And the consultancy company is not the home for tax: ICAI's definition of Management Consultancy & Other Services "shall not include the function of statutory or periodical audit, tax (both direct taxes and indirect taxes) representation or advice concerning tax matters". Tax stays with the CA firm or LLP.

Where the real line falls: audit against the rest, not audit against tax

The page title talks about audit and tax, and many firms do split that way in practice. ICAI's text draws the line elsewhere. For tax, the Code says return preparation "does not usually create a threat" because it rests on historical information and the tax authority reviews it (para 604.6 A1). It adds that tax services can create a self-review threat "when there is a risk that the results of the services will affect the accounting records or the financial statements" (para 604.3 A1), for example tax calculations for the accounting entries.

The hard limits sit with accounting and book-keeping. For an audit client that is not a public interest entity, the firm may not provide them "unless the services are of a routine or mechanical nature" and any threats are addressed (para R601.5). For a public interest entity, a service that creates a self-review threat is not allowed at all (para R600.17).

There is also a fee limit. ICAI's notification 1-CA(7)/60/2002 of 8 March 2002 says a statutory auditor of a public sector undertaking, government company, listed company or other public company with turnover of ₹50 crore or more is guilty of professional misconduct if he accepts other work from the same company for fees above the statutory audit fee. It counts the auditor and its associate concerns together, and ICAI's corporate-form guidelines apply it to the consultancy company too.

A worked example: two entities, one client

A Kolkata practice runs Mondal & Associates LLP (the audit and tax entity) and Mondal Advisory Pvt Ltd, a registered management consultancy company. The client, Rai Agro Pvt Ltd, is a private company in West Bengal. Every name and number here is invented to show the shape.

The LLP is the statutory auditor and also files the company's income-tax return, which the Code treats as a service that does not usually create a threat. The consultancy company is asked for a market study for a new plant, an item on ICAI's consultancy list ("market research and demand studies"). Before the engagement letter, a partner records why this is not one of the section 144 services and why the audit team will not rely on it (the Code asks for documentation: para R400.60). That recorded judgment is the real control. The software cannot make it for you.

The two entities are separate registered persons under GST. A GSTIN is built from the state code, the PAN and an entity code (rule 10 of the CGST Rules), and a different legal entity has a different PAN. So the LLP and the company each have their own GSTIN, their own invoice series and their own return.

One client, two entities, two sets of paper. Fees and numbers are illustrative.
Mondal & Associates LLPMondal Advisory Pvt Ltd
Work for Rai AgroStatutory audit and ITR-6Market study for a new plant
GSTIN19AAAAA1111A1Z5 (own)19BBBBB2222B1Z8 (own)
Invoice numberMA/26-27/0042MAD/26-27/0007
Fee before GST₹1,20,000 audit + ₹15,000 ITR = ₹1,35,000₹60,000
CGST + SGST at 9% each₹12,150 + ₹12,150₹5,400 + ₹5,400
Invoice total₹1,59,300₹70,800
Paid intoThe LLP's own bank accountThe company's own bank account
ReturnOwn GSTR-1 and GSTR-3BOwn GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B

Rule 46(b) of the CGST Rules wants a consecutive serial number of up to sixteen characters, unique for the financial year. Two entities cannot share one series, because each would show gaps where the other's invoices took numbers. The client pays two invoices into two accounts. A single cheque for ₹2,30,100 would force one entity to hold the other's money, so ask the client to pay each invoice separately.

The fee ceiling does not bite here, because Rai Agro is a private company. Had it been a listed company of ₹50 crore turnover or more, the consultancy fee and any other non-audit fee, taken together, could not exceed the ₹1,20,000 audit fee.

How T4Suite handles the entities

T4Suite keeps each entity as a master with its own GSTIN, registration status, state and bank details. A client is linked to one or more entities. Every task belongs to one entity, and the bill raised from it is issued by that entity. An entity with a series gets its own numbers: a prefix of up to eight capital letters, digits, slashes or hyphens, the financial year, and a count that restarts at 1 each 1 April, such as DKA/26-27/0042.

It will not issue a bill from a GST-registered entity that lacks a GSTIN, or from any entity without bank details. An entity with no series set up keeps billing from the firm's older shared INV- counter, so give each entity its own. The firm can keep entities apart: people see the entities they are members of, and somebody with firm-wide scope sees all. A setting called Keep entities apart controls whether that wall is on.

What it does not do matters just as much. T4Suite does not know which entity audits which client, and it will not warn you that the advisory entity should not take an assignment. The independence check stays with the partner. ICAI's Guidelines on Ethical Issues, 2026 (from 1 April 2026) ask each firm to keep a cash book, a ledger and a bill register, and separate entities mean separate registers.

Questions firms ask

Why can't a firm audit a company and also provide its other services?

Because of the self-review threat: a firm cannot appropriately evaluate its own work. Section 144 of the Companies Act, 2013 bars the statutory auditor from accounting and book keeping, internal audit, financial information system design, actuarial, investment advisory, investment banking, outsourced financial services and management services, directly or indirectly. The Board or audit committee must approve any other service.

Does a separate company or LLP get around section 144?

No. The Explanation to section 144 extends "directly or indirectly" to services rendered through the auditor's partners, its parent, subsidiary or associate entity, or any entity it controls or whose name or brand it uses. ICAI's Code applies the same idea to network firms, whether or not they are legally separate.

Can a company do audit or tax work for a CA practice?

No to audit. Section 25 of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 says no company shall practise as chartered accountants, and ICAI's corporate-form guidelines say no audit practice can be done in corporate form. A registered management consultancy company may do only the listed consultancy services, and ICAI's definition excludes tax advice and representation.

Can a CA firm do the audit and file the same client's income-tax return?

ICAI's Code says tax return preparation "does not usually create a threat" (para 604.6 A1). It can create a self-review threat where the result affects the financial statements, and the firm must assess that, and document it, before accepting the work.

Do two entities need separate GSTINs and invoice series?

Yes. Each legal entity has its own PAN, so it has its own GSTIN (rule 10 of the CGST Rules), and rule 46(b) wants a consecutive serial number unique for the financial year. Each entity issues invoices from its own series, collects into its own bank account and files its own GST returns.

See T4Suite on your own practice

A short walkthrough, mapped to your firm's entities and services.

Book a demo